Ideas have a latent power to either empower or destroy humanity — on all edges of that sword, good public debate can help to prevent the extremes and advance the causes of good.
From World War 1 and 2 to the Rwandan genocide, humanity has come to attest the downside of bad ideas. Ideas have seen the empowerment of billions of people, yet they also have caused the death of billions of people.
In Nazi Germany, the Nazis believed that the Aryan race was superior to all other races, and they used this belief to justify their persecution and extermination of Jews, Roma, and other groups that they considered to be inferior.
The Nazi philosophy was based on a number of false ideas, including the idea that there is a hierarchy of races, the idea that some races are inherently superior to others, and the idea that violence is justified in order to achieve racial purity. These ideas are all false and harmful, and they have no basis in reality.
Many sources have argued that the Rwandan genocide was catalysed by Hutu extremism. In the years leading up to the genocide, Hutu extremists began to spread propaganda that demonized the Tutsis. They portrayed the Tutsis as a threat to the Hutu way of life, and they called for their extermination.
The Rwandan Genocide is a reminder of the dangers of bad philosophy/lies. When people believe that there are certain groups of people who are inferior, it can lead to violence and genocide. We must all work to combat bad philosophy and promote tolerance and understanding.
Bad policies have ruined billions of people’s lives in a number of ways.
Here are a few examples:
- Poverty: Bad policies that lead to poverty can have a devastating impact on people’s lives. Poverty can lead to hunger, homelessness, disease, and a lack of access to education and healthcare.
- War: Bad policies that lead to war can also have a devastating impact on people’s lives. War can lead to death, injury, displacement, and a loss of livelihood.
- Climate change: Bad policies that contribute to climate change can have a devastating impact on people’s lives. Climate change can lead to more extreme weather events, such as floods, droughts, and hurricanes. These events can lead to death, injury, displacement, and a loss of livelihood.
- Discrimination: Bad policies that discriminate against certain groups of people can have a devastating impact on those groups’ lives. Discrimination can lead to a lack of access to education, healthcare, and employment. It can also lead to violence and harassment.
Let me shed bring forth more pragmatic examples on this:
- The British Raj in India is estimated to have caused the deaths of 30 million people through famine and disease.
- The Atlantic slave trade is estimated to have caused the deaths of 15 million people.
- The Soviet Union’s collectivization of agriculture is estimated to have caused the deaths of 5 million people.
- The Great Leap Forward in China is estimated to have caused the deaths of 45 million people.
One of the debates over ownership has been a debate on the above quote on whether it was Yung or Dostoevsky that coined it. Nonetheless, the quote speaks to the relationship between ideas/philosophies and those who believe those ideas.
The quote “People don’t have/own ideas, ideas have/own people” is often attributed to Carl Jung, a Swiss psychiatrist and psychoanalyst. Jung believed that ideas are not simply products of the mind, but rather they have a life of their own. They can take hold of people, motivating them to act in certain ways. In this sense, ideas can be seen as having a kind of power over people.
There is some evidence to support Jung’s view. For example, studies have shown that people are more likely to be persuaded by ideas that are consistent with their own beliefs and values. This suggests that ideas can have a powerful influence on our thoughts and behavior.
Of course, not all ideas are created equal. Some ideas are more powerful than others. The most powerful ideas are those that are simple, clear, and easy to understand. They are also ideas that resonate with people’s emotions. When an idea is both simple and emotionally resonant, it can be very difficult to resist.
In the end, it is up to each individual to decide whether or not to embrace an idea. However, it is important to remember that ideas can have a powerful influence on our lives. We should be careful about the ideas that we allow to take hold of us.
When something owns you, you loose a certain ability of control over yourself. You can subconsciously absorb the negatives of the ideas without your conscious acceptance of the same.
In the popular series Peaky Blinders, an episode is devoted to how the Protagonist — Thomas Shelby did to put their affairs in order after learning of a strange disease (Which later was realised to be a lie).
Before Thomas realized that it was a lie, he had done a lot just before that floating his wealth in the family trusts, having the worst nightmares and living on the edge every day of his life.
The role of Public Debate in disempowering bad ideas
Debate can play a role in breaking down bad ideas or philosophy by exposing the flaws in those ideas. When people are forced to defend their ideas in a public forum, they are more likely to be challenged on their assumptions and arguments. This can lead to them reconsidering their positions, or at least being more open to other points of view.
In addition, debate can help to educate the public about bad ideas and philosophy. When people hear different perspectives on an issue, they are better able to form their own opinions. This can help to prevent the spread of bad ideas and philosophy and can lead to a more informed and engaged citizenry.
Of course, debate is not always effective in breaking down bad ideas or philosophy. Sometimes, people are so entrenched in their beliefs that they are unwilling to listen to any other point of view. However, even in these cases, debate can still be valuable. By exposing the flaws in bad ideas, debate can help to weaken their appeal and make them less likely to be adopted by others.
Here are some ways in which debate can help in this process:
- Identifying logical fallacies: Through debate, individuals can identify and expose logical fallacies present in arguments supporting bad ideas or philosophies. By highlighting flaws in reasoning, participants can effectively dismantle weak arguments and bring attention to inconsistencies or errors in thinking.
- Encouraging critical thinking: Debate promotes critical thinking skills by challenging individuals to analyze and evaluate ideas from multiple perspectives. This process allows for a more nuanced understanding of complex topics and helps individuals discern the strengths and weaknesses of various viewpoints.
- Providing counterarguments: Debate offers a platform for presenting counterarguments against bad ideas or philosophies. By engaging in reasoned discourse, participants can put forth alternative perspectives, evidence, and examples that challenge and undermine flawed concepts. This enables a more comprehensive evaluation of ideas and encourages individuals to question their own beliefs.
- Fact-checking and evidence-based reasoning: Debate provides an opportunity to fact-check claims and assertions. Participants can demand evidence and logical reasoning to support arguments, thereby highlighting any lack of substantiation or reliance on misinformation. This process helps separate unsupported claims from evidence-based conclusions and fosters a more reliable and informed understanding of the subject matter.
- Public exposure and accountability: Debate often takes place in public forums, allowing bad ideas or flawed philosophies to be subject to public scrutiny. This exposure can contribute to the accountability of proponents and force them to defend their positions with clarity and coherence. Public debates also provide an opportunity for a wider audience to evaluate arguments and make more informed judgments.
- Promoting dialogue and understanding: Debate creates a space for open dialogue and the exchange of ideas. By actively listening to opposing viewpoints and engaging in respectful discussions, individuals can gain a deeper understanding of the underlying assumptions and motivations behind bad ideas. This increased understanding can facilitate productive conversations and potentially lead to the transformation or abandonment of flawed ideologies.
Ideas have a latent power to either empower or destroy humanity — on all edges of that sword, good public debate can help to prevent the extremes and advance the causes of good.
For more information or feedback on this piece, send an email to [email protected]